diff --git a/content/reviews/books/swan-song.md b/content/reviews/books/swan-song.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ef45136 --- /dev/null +++ b/content/reviews/books/swan-song.md @@ -0,0 +1,54 @@ ++++ +title = "Swan Song - Robert R. McCammon" +date = 2020-11-18 + +[taxonomies] +tags = ["books", "reviews", "fiction", "2020 challenge", "3 stars"] ++++ + +[GoodReads Summary](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12972591-swan-song): +Swan is a nine-year-old Idaho girl following her struggling mother from one +trailer park to the next when she receives visions of doom—something far wider +than the narrow scope of her own beleaguered life. In a blinding flash, nuclear +bombs annihilate civilization, leaving only a few buried survivors to crawl +onto a scorched landscape that was once America. + + + +{{ stars(stars=3) }} + +I'm a sucker for disaster movies, so it could be that a disaster book (would +also pick my attention. And it did, in a way. + +There is this huge disaster of nuclear bombs falling over US and Russia, and a +few survivors have to take care of themselves. All set for a good story, but +things get in the way of it. + +For example, the girl in the title (and summary): It could be interesting to +explore how someone so young would be a survivor in a place completely +destroyed, but she shows some special powers that are never explained -- and +no, it was not the radiation from the bombs, a là Marvel super-heroes. + +There is the bag lady in a quest that may be the only story that really fits +the context: A survivor of the streets, now trying to survive in the rumble of +civilization. + +And there is the plot from the people who got shelter in a made-up bunker, +which should be used only for recreation purposes ("This is how you'd live if +this was a real bunker and there was a nuclear strike outside") that got caught +in the middle, which should be a good exploration, but end up being the story +that could be ripped out of the whole with very little loss. And sadly, that's +not just this plot that gets unnecessary stuff: Fights that lead to nowhere, +longs explanation of clothing people are wearing that affect absolutely nothing +in the whole and on and on. + +On top of that, there is a [MacGuffin +device](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacGuffin) floating around that is never +explained how it works, how it came to be, it's used once, in a test, providing +a complete game changer which is never used again after that. + +So you end up with an unexplained phenomena (actually, more than one, as the +story progressed), something interesting and a bunch of completely unnecessary +stuff. I read somewhere that there were talks to make the book a movie, which +would be hard for a 900+ book, but if you consider the amount of stuff that +doesn't add anything, sure, it fits fine in an around-two-hours movie.