Browse Source

Merge branch 'release/20200512'

master
Julio Biason 5 years ago
parent
commit
e322336947
  1. 42
      content/reviews/books/fledgling.md
  2. 61
      content/reviews/books/rust-in-action.md

42
content/reviews/books/fledgling.md

@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+++
title = "Fledgling - Sharon Lee, Steve Miller"
date = 2020-05-12
[taxonomies]
tags = ["books", "reviews", "scifi", "liaden universe"]
+++
[GoodReads Summary](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5585180-fledgling):
Theo Waitley has lived all her young life on Delgado, a Safe World that is
home to one of the galaxy's premier institutions of higher learning. Both
Theo's mother, Kamele, and Kamele's onagrata Jen Sar Kiladi, are professors at
the university, and they all live comfortably together, just like they have
for all of Theo's life, in Jen Sar's house at the outskirts of town.
<!-- more -->
{{ stars(stars=2) }}
First things first: I did enjoy the fact that the universe has gender roles
inverted -- with women being considered "strong" and "intellectual" and men
being the ones that want to look pretty -- and this is not throw at your face
at every moment, although it gets explicit by the end of the book, but by
then, you're already good with it.
On the other hand, some things feel... weird. Not about the genders, but in
the story itself. There is some great secret, something the main characters
want to hide, doing a lot of schemes to conceal it and when it is said what it
is... it feels dumb. Ok, someone is clumsy, but that's natural in someone's
family and WHY THE HECK IS THAT A SECRET?!?
Also weird are some dialogues. At some point, there is one character asking a
question and getting annoyed at it at the same time, like he didn't like to
hear the question he just asked. Some discussions just jump into conclusions
-- in the right conclusions -- which, again, feels weird. And there is a short
arc in the middle of it that leads absolutely nowhere. It is throw in the
story, affects absolutely nothing and goes away without a trace.
Maybe it's because I got the book from Humble Bundle and jumped straight into
the 12 book of the series (the "Liaden Universe", although this is the first
book about a sub-series of one of the characters, or so it seems), but I
didn't feel compelled by any of the characters.

61
content/reviews/books/rust-in-action.md

@ -0,0 +1,61 @@
+++
title = "Rust In Action - T.S. McNamara"
date = 2020-04-28
[taxonomies]
tags = ["books", "reviews", "rust", "t s mcnamara"]
+++
[GoodReads Summary](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/45731908-rust-in-action):
Rust in Action introduces the Rust programming language by exploring numerous
systems programming concepts and techniques. You'll be learning Rust by delving
into how computers work under the hood. You'll find yourself playing with
persistent storage, memory, networking and even tinkering with CPU
instructions. The book takes you through using Rust to extend other
applications and teaches you tricks to write blindingly fast code. You'll also
discover parallel and concurrent programming. Filled to the brim with
real-life use-cases and scenarios, you'll go beyond the Rust syntax and see
what Rust has to offer in real-world use cases.
<!-- more -->
{{ stars(stars=4) }}
{% note() %}
The version of this book I got is not the final version, it's part of
Manning Early Access Program, which allows people to read and participate in
"constructing" a book. A lot of things may change in the final version, so be
aware of this.
{% end %}
I have to say, I don't buy the "introduces the Rust programming language" part
of the description. A few points seem related to people that already have some
knowledge about the language, and jumping straight to some non-trivial problem
appears to skip a few "introduction" points, in my opinion.
One have to ask what "in Action" means. Sure, you'll write your one RFC
754 for dealing with floating points, so you can understand why some floating
values get to 6.000000000001, and while you won't ever write your own floating
point processor, you have to ask yourself: What is being explained about Rust
here? Sometimes, the problems feel more like "I want to solve this" than "I
want to explain this feature of the language", while it should be the other
way around.
Another confusing point: The output of a program appears before its code.
While not that weird, you end up with some sections showing the output,
explaining a bit and then, way later, you get the code what actually produces
that output. I remember reading a bit about the output and some discussion
about it and I got really confused about what was producing that output.
The Rust part seems a bit out-of-date, too. There are some `extern crate`,
which is optional at this point. Updating the code to reflect the latest
version of the language (the syntax, that is) would be better.
On the other hand, I have to give the author the props for managing to explain
things _really well_. Why you should use something, how can you apply
different things to the same data and so on. That's the book greatest
strength.
So, is it a bad book? Not at all. It has some quirks, but overall is well
explained and, if you keep an eye on the language from outside, it answers a
lot of stuff that you won't figure out anywhere else.
Loading…
Cancel
Save